Menu

The expanding scope of the Coronavirus has created uncertainty and anxiety on a global scale, encompassing both public health and economic impacts. As business leaders around the world grapple with a wide range of questions, Paul Hastings is here to help.

 

RECENT ARTICLES

Recent Articles

PH COVID-19 Client Alert Series: CARES Act Fraud Risks for Borrowers and Lenders

Apr 28, 2020, 14:26 PM
Publication Type(s):
Client Alerts
Exlcude on home page:
No

The U.S. Small Business Administration’s (“SBA”) Paycheck Protection Program (“PPP”) launched on April 3, 2020, and in less than two weeks the allocated $349 billion in PPP funds was exhausted. On April 24, 2020, a supplemental relief package with an additional $310 billion in PPP funds was signed into law.

Given the significant volume of funding being provided in such a quick timeline, difficulties inevitably will arise in complying with statutory and regulatory requirements during the PPP lending process. This volume of expeditious funding carries an inherent risk of fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement. As has been the case with other emergency federal funding, we expect prosecutors will take an aggressive approach in investigating and pursuing allegations of fraud in connection with the use of PPP funds, for both borrowers and lenders.  Earlier today, April 28, 2020, Treasury Secretary Mnuchin made clear that companies can and will face criminal liability for fraud in connection with the receipt of SBA relief funds.1

CARES Act Oversight Provisions

Congress and the Attorney General have already made clear that fraud in connection with the procurement and use of Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (“CARES Act”) loans and grants will be investigated and prosecuted aggressively. In a March 16, 2020 memorandum to the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”), the Attorney General urged federal prosecutors to “prioritize the detection, investigation, and prosecution of all criminal conduct related to the current pandemic.”2

The CARES Act specifically includes several provisions to fund oversight and enforcement of fraud related to the distribution of SBA relief funds, including utilizing existing Offices of the Inspector General (“OIG”) in several federal agencies and creating a new Office of the Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery (“SIGPR”).3 These include:

  • Authorizing criminal penalties, under existing law, for fraud or other misconduct in seeking or using the SBA’s relief funds (Section 1109(i));
  • Creating the SIGPR Office within the U.S. Department of Treasury to coordinate the auditing and investigation of management and spending of funds under any program established under the CARES Act, including the investigation and prosecution of fraud in the procurement and use of CARES Act loans (Section 4018); and
  • Establishing a Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, composed of several Inspectors General, responsible for preventing and detecting fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement of all funds made available to any non-federal entity under the CARES Act, with the authority to conduct a comprehensive audit of all contracts entered into by the federal government pursuant to the CARES Act (Section 15010).

We previously saw aggressive investigations and enforcement actions by the DOJ, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), and other regulators against financial institutions and their senior executives related to the use of TARP funds following the 2008 Financial Crisis. Now, SIGPR has been given a broad mandate to “conduct, supervise, and coordinate audits and investigations” in connection with the CARES Act, which will likely mean the issuance of large numbers of subpoenas and the referral of cases to the DOJ for at least the five years provided by the CARES Act.

Fraud Risks for Borrowers in PPP Applications

As a general matter, any businesses applying for federal funds should take care to ensure that applications, certifications, and any reporting to the government in connection with the funds, are accurate. This diligence is essential given the potential investigative risks and liabilities related to any “fraud on the government,” including:

  • Criminal penalties (prison time and/or fines) for false statements in connection with the PPP, as authorized by the Inspector General Act of 1978, or under other laws criminalizing false statements or fraudulent schemes;
  • Criminal or significant civil liability under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), which carries large penalties for entities and individuals who defraud the government;
  • Criminal or civil liability from audits or investigations connected to the expanded oversight activities by SIGPR; or
  • Qui tam actions brought by whistleblowers.

Businesses must take time to consider whether they are the type of business for which PPP funds are intended from a common-sense perspective, particularly with continued media scrutiny of certain large entities that received PPP loans. Large businesses or small entities owned by large businesses are not necessarily precluded from applying for PPP loans, but they must be able to truthfully establish eligibility within the guidance. Secretary Mnuchin made clear on April 28, 2020 that all companies that received more than $2 million in small business loans would be audited by the SBA and subject to potential criminal liability if it is later determined that they were ineligible for the SBA relief funds.4  In fact, some large companies that received tens of millions of dollars of SBA loans have already announced plans to return the PPP funds due to public criticism of their participation, although they have not made any acknowledgments regarding their eligibility to receive the funds in the first place.5

Last week, on April 21, 2020, Secretary Mnuchin announced that the SBA may “give people the benefit of the doubt” if there were any misunderstandings about PPP certifications and a borrower immediately pays back the loan.6 The SBA updated guidance on April 26, 2020 confirms that ineligible borrowers may repay any PPP loan received in full by May 7, 2020 to “be deemed by SBA to have made the required certification [of eligibility] in good faith.”7 As part of the updated guidance, the Treasury and SBA have clarified the certification requirements for borrowers to the extent there was confusion, noting that only entities without access to other forms of capital, such as selling shares or debt, are eligible for the SBA relief funds.8  Businesses that have already received PPP loans should strongly consider whether their certifications regarding loan eligibility will withstand investigative scrutiny and assess whether to take advantage of the opportunity to return the funds by May 7th to avoid potential future criminal or regulatory exposure.

Fraud Risks for Lenders

While it is unlikely that financial institutions will be the principal focus of SIGPR or related DOJ investigations, they will inevitably become involved when such investigations begin. The SBA has declared that lenders’ underwriting obligations under the PPP are limited; the SBA has explicitly stated that lenders may rely on borrowers’ representations and certifications in the loan process. In fact, to ensure the new PPP loans reached recipients quickly, banks were largely absolved of the time-consuming responsibility of checking for fraud or egregious errors in loan applications, so long as borrowers provided necessary documentation.9 However, it remains unclear whether such lender protections extend to all of the many potential ways in which lenders may be held accountable in hindsight for borrower misrepresentations made in those applications.

It is unfortunate but expected that lenders will be involved in FCA and criminal CARES Act fraud inquiries. As financial institutions know well, these inquiries frequently include investigations related to the conduct of lenders, including their internal processes and controls, documentation, diligence, and relationship banker behavior.

While the SBA’s Interim Final Rule requires only limited due diligence on the part of lenders, it nonetheless requires that lenders “follow their existing [Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”)] protocols when making PPP loans.”10 Prosecutors may therefore also inquire about whether banks followed their own BSA protocols, as well as regulatory or statutory requirements, which could lead to criminal or civil exposure for financial institutions.

In addition, the SIGPR mandate includes a requirement that it investigate fraud in the “sale of loans” in the secondary markets. This is likely to include inquiries into representations made as part of securitizations or the sale of loan participations. Any alleged false statements made in connection with this type of market activity can be the source of a separate investigation of a financial institution related to the CARES Act.

Best Practices for Lenders to Mitigate Risks

Financial institutions have admittedly been thrust in the middle of a rushed loan program with limited guidance and little time to prepare. Nevertheless, banks and bankers must remain vigilant to do what they can in the shortened and urgent application process to identify questionable representations. To avoid potential criminal and regulatory exposure, transparency and accuracy are especially important in the execution of applications for SBA loans under the CARES Act. To the extent possible, financial institutions should:

  1. Create and implement clear, documented processes for assessing the truthfulness of representations in CARES Act loan applications, including a review by compliance personnel, or at a minimum, a bank employee other than the relationship banker;
  2. Document any discussion with a borrower regarding a close question about eligibility or necessity for PPP funds under the law, and require a second review of any application where such a close question is involved;
  3. Confirm that borrowers do not have an alternate source of available funding, such as from a significant shareholder;
  4. Require relationship bankers to regularly seek and maintain documentation regarding any changes in a borrower’s investments or relationships with other business entities or affiliates that may affect eligibility or the eligibility certification;
  5. Collect any description of steps taken by a borrower to establish eligibility (e.g., any amendments to governance documents to irrevocably change control rights between affiliates);
  6. Collect additional documentation from borrowers, beyond the minimum requirements, demonstrating, for example, a decline in available funding through orders, ongoing business operations, or changes in the circumstances of a business’s customers;
  7. Compare borrowers’ assertions about payroll, rent, and other expenses with the Know Your Customer (“KYC”) information in the bank’s files;
  8. Compare any information in a borrower’s files about their affiliates with the list of affiliates that borrowers provide in their CARES Act loan applications, particularly for the counting of affiliate employees for eligibility purposes;
  9. Conduct diligence on the certification that borrowers will be required to submit attesting to the use of loan proceeds in order to obtain loan forgiveness as issues may arise if activity in borrowers’ bank accounts is inconsistent with loan application representations;
  10. Prepare trainings for relevant personnel on the CARES Act funding requirements and any subsequent guidance issued; and
  11. Review internal BSA policies and prepare regular BSA trainings and compliance alerts for bankers during this time.

While there is a need for financial institutions to act quickly to process CARES Act loan applications, basic compliance procedures and borrower diligence cannot be ignored. Incomplete or inadequate diligence or controls create investigative risks for both lenders and borrowers.



1 “As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

2   Memorandum from the Attorney General to all United States Attorneys, COVID-19 – Department of Justice Priorities (Mar. 16, 2020), available at https://www.justice.gov/ag/page/file/1258676/download.

3  Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, H.R. 748, §§ 4018, 4020, 15010 (2020).

4 As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

5 Id.

7  Paycheck Protection Loans, Frequently Asked Questions (Apr. 26, 2020) available at https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/136/Paycheck-Protection-Program-Frequently-Asked-Questions.pdf.

8 Id.

9 Bob Davis, “SBA to Face Big Challenges Ensuring Coronavirus Loans Aren’t Misspent,” Wall St. J. (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/sba-to-face-big-challenges-ensuring-coronavirus-loans-arent-misspent-11588094140.

10   13 CFR 120.

IsRss:
  • cares act
  • client alerts

Related professionals

18 comments

Leave a comment
  1. roger lagasca | Jul 10, 2020
    Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks, I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link  to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  hi was just seeing if you minded a comment. i like your website and the thme you picked is super. I will be back.
  2. rogerlagasca | Jul 10, 2020
    I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The web site style is perfect, the articles is really great cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  I am unable to read articles online very often, but I’m glad I did today.  This is very well written and your points are well-expressed.  Please, don’t ever stop writing.
  3. muqeet | Jul 09, 2020
    hello!! Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community. siesta bar stool
  4. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
  5. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
    Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include. บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.
  6. Michel jorden | Jul 08, 2020
  7. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
    This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value. Im glad to have found this post as its such an interesting one! I am always on the lookout for quality posts and articles so i suppose im lucky to have found this! I hope you will be adding more in the future...
  8. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
    Great knowledge, do anyone mind merely reference back to it situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your site. You have some really great posts and I feel I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please send me an email if interested. Thank you!
  9. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
  10. Michel jorden | Jul 06, 2020
  11. rogerlagasca | Jul 06, 2020
    I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well..  smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
  12. rogerlagasca | Jul 03, 2020
  13. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
    Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. 
  14. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
  15. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
  16. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
  17. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020
    Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject. smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject.
  18. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020

    Leave a comment

    Client Alert

    PH COVID-19 Client Alert Series: CARES Act Fraud Risks for Borrowers and Lenders

    Apr 28, 2020, 14:26 PM
    Publication Type(s):
    Client Alerts
    Exlcude on home page:
    No

    The U.S. Small Business Administration’s (“SBA”) Paycheck Protection Program (“PPP”) launched on April 3, 2020, and in less than two weeks the allocated $349 billion in PPP funds was exhausted. On April 24, 2020, a supplemental relief package with an additional $310 billion in PPP funds was signed into law.

    Given the significant volume of funding being provided in such a quick timeline, difficulties inevitably will arise in complying with statutory and regulatory requirements during the PPP lending process. This volume of expeditious funding carries an inherent risk of fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement. As has been the case with other emergency federal funding, we expect prosecutors will take an aggressive approach in investigating and pursuing allegations of fraud in connection with the use of PPP funds, for both borrowers and lenders.  Earlier today, April 28, 2020, Treasury Secretary Mnuchin made clear that companies can and will face criminal liability for fraud in connection with the receipt of SBA relief funds.1

    CARES Act Oversight Provisions

    Congress and the Attorney General have already made clear that fraud in connection with the procurement and use of Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (“CARES Act”) loans and grants will be investigated and prosecuted aggressively. In a March 16, 2020 memorandum to the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”), the Attorney General urged federal prosecutors to “prioritize the detection, investigation, and prosecution of all criminal conduct related to the current pandemic.”2

    The CARES Act specifically includes several provisions to fund oversight and enforcement of fraud related to the distribution of SBA relief funds, including utilizing existing Offices of the Inspector General (“OIG”) in several federal agencies and creating a new Office of the Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery (“SIGPR”).3 These include:

    • Authorizing criminal penalties, under existing law, for fraud or other misconduct in seeking or using the SBA’s relief funds (Section 1109(i));
    • Creating the SIGPR Office within the U.S. Department of Treasury to coordinate the auditing and investigation of management and spending of funds under any program established under the CARES Act, including the investigation and prosecution of fraud in the procurement and use of CARES Act loans (Section 4018); and
    • Establishing a Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, composed of several Inspectors General, responsible for preventing and detecting fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement of all funds made available to any non-federal entity under the CARES Act, with the authority to conduct a comprehensive audit of all contracts entered into by the federal government pursuant to the CARES Act (Section 15010).

    We previously saw aggressive investigations and enforcement actions by the DOJ, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), and other regulators against financial institutions and their senior executives related to the use of TARP funds following the 2008 Financial Crisis. Now, SIGPR has been given a broad mandate to “conduct, supervise, and coordinate audits and investigations” in connection with the CARES Act, which will likely mean the issuance of large numbers of subpoenas and the referral of cases to the DOJ for at least the five years provided by the CARES Act.

    Fraud Risks for Borrowers in PPP Applications

    As a general matter, any businesses applying for federal funds should take care to ensure that applications, certifications, and any reporting to the government in connection with the funds, are accurate. This diligence is essential given the potential investigative risks and liabilities related to any “fraud on the government,” including:

    • Criminal penalties (prison time and/or fines) for false statements in connection with the PPP, as authorized by the Inspector General Act of 1978, or under other laws criminalizing false statements or fraudulent schemes;
    • Criminal or significant civil liability under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), which carries large penalties for entities and individuals who defraud the government;
    • Criminal or civil liability from audits or investigations connected to the expanded oversight activities by SIGPR; or
    • Qui tam actions brought by whistleblowers.

    Businesses must take time to consider whether they are the type of business for which PPP funds are intended from a common-sense perspective, particularly with continued media scrutiny of certain large entities that received PPP loans. Large businesses or small entities owned by large businesses are not necessarily precluded from applying for PPP loans, but they must be able to truthfully establish eligibility within the guidance. Secretary Mnuchin made clear on April 28, 2020 that all companies that received more than $2 million in small business loans would be audited by the SBA and subject to potential criminal liability if it is later determined that they were ineligible for the SBA relief funds.4  In fact, some large companies that received tens of millions of dollars of SBA loans have already announced plans to return the PPP funds due to public criticism of their participation, although they have not made any acknowledgments regarding their eligibility to receive the funds in the first place.5

    Last week, on April 21, 2020, Secretary Mnuchin announced that the SBA may “give people the benefit of the doubt” if there were any misunderstandings about PPP certifications and a borrower immediately pays back the loan.6 The SBA updated guidance on April 26, 2020 confirms that ineligible borrowers may repay any PPP loan received in full by May 7, 2020 to “be deemed by SBA to have made the required certification [of eligibility] in good faith.”7 As part of the updated guidance, the Treasury and SBA have clarified the certification requirements for borrowers to the extent there was confusion, noting that only entities without access to other forms of capital, such as selling shares or debt, are eligible for the SBA relief funds.8  Businesses that have already received PPP loans should strongly consider whether their certifications regarding loan eligibility will withstand investigative scrutiny and assess whether to take advantage of the opportunity to return the funds by May 7th to avoid potential future criminal or regulatory exposure.

    Fraud Risks for Lenders

    While it is unlikely that financial institutions will be the principal focus of SIGPR or related DOJ investigations, they will inevitably become involved when such investigations begin. The SBA has declared that lenders’ underwriting obligations under the PPP are limited; the SBA has explicitly stated that lenders may rely on borrowers’ representations and certifications in the loan process. In fact, to ensure the new PPP loans reached recipients quickly, banks were largely absolved of the time-consuming responsibility of checking for fraud or egregious errors in loan applications, so long as borrowers provided necessary documentation.9 However, it remains unclear whether such lender protections extend to all of the many potential ways in which lenders may be held accountable in hindsight for borrower misrepresentations made in those applications.

    It is unfortunate but expected that lenders will be involved in FCA and criminal CARES Act fraud inquiries. As financial institutions know well, these inquiries frequently include investigations related to the conduct of lenders, including their internal processes and controls, documentation, diligence, and relationship banker behavior.

    While the SBA’s Interim Final Rule requires only limited due diligence on the part of lenders, it nonetheless requires that lenders “follow their existing [Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”)] protocols when making PPP loans.”10 Prosecutors may therefore also inquire about whether banks followed their own BSA protocols, as well as regulatory or statutory requirements, which could lead to criminal or civil exposure for financial institutions.

    In addition, the SIGPR mandate includes a requirement that it investigate fraud in the “sale of loans” in the secondary markets. This is likely to include inquiries into representations made as part of securitizations or the sale of loan participations. Any alleged false statements made in connection with this type of market activity can be the source of a separate investigation of a financial institution related to the CARES Act.

    Best Practices for Lenders to Mitigate Risks

    Financial institutions have admittedly been thrust in the middle of a rushed loan program with limited guidance and little time to prepare. Nevertheless, banks and bankers must remain vigilant to do what they can in the shortened and urgent application process to identify questionable representations. To avoid potential criminal and regulatory exposure, transparency and accuracy are especially important in the execution of applications for SBA loans under the CARES Act. To the extent possible, financial institutions should:

    1. Create and implement clear, documented processes for assessing the truthfulness of representations in CARES Act loan applications, including a review by compliance personnel, or at a minimum, a bank employee other than the relationship banker;
    2. Document any discussion with a borrower regarding a close question about eligibility or necessity for PPP funds under the law, and require a second review of any application where such a close question is involved;
    3. Confirm that borrowers do not have an alternate source of available funding, such as from a significant shareholder;
    4. Require relationship bankers to regularly seek and maintain documentation regarding any changes in a borrower’s investments or relationships with other business entities or affiliates that may affect eligibility or the eligibility certification;
    5. Collect any description of steps taken by a borrower to establish eligibility (e.g., any amendments to governance documents to irrevocably change control rights between affiliates);
    6. Collect additional documentation from borrowers, beyond the minimum requirements, demonstrating, for example, a decline in available funding through orders, ongoing business operations, or changes in the circumstances of a business’s customers;
    7. Compare borrowers’ assertions about payroll, rent, and other expenses with the Know Your Customer (“KYC”) information in the bank’s files;
    8. Compare any information in a borrower’s files about their affiliates with the list of affiliates that borrowers provide in their CARES Act loan applications, particularly for the counting of affiliate employees for eligibility purposes;
    9. Conduct diligence on the certification that borrowers will be required to submit attesting to the use of loan proceeds in order to obtain loan forgiveness as issues may arise if activity in borrowers’ bank accounts is inconsistent with loan application representations;
    10. Prepare trainings for relevant personnel on the CARES Act funding requirements and any subsequent guidance issued; and
    11. Review internal BSA policies and prepare regular BSA trainings and compliance alerts for bankers during this time.

    While there is a need for financial institutions to act quickly to process CARES Act loan applications, basic compliance procedures and borrower diligence cannot be ignored. Incomplete or inadequate diligence or controls create investigative risks for both lenders and borrowers.



    1 “As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

    2   Memorandum from the Attorney General to all United States Attorneys, COVID-19 – Department of Justice Priorities (Mar. 16, 2020), available at https://www.justice.gov/ag/page/file/1258676/download.

    3  Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, H.R. 748, §§ 4018, 4020, 15010 (2020).

    4 As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

    5 Id.

    7  Paycheck Protection Loans, Frequently Asked Questions (Apr. 26, 2020) available at https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/136/Paycheck-Protection-Program-Frequently-Asked-Questions.pdf.

    8 Id.

    9 Bob Davis, “SBA to Face Big Challenges Ensuring Coronavirus Loans Aren’t Misspent,” Wall St. J. (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/sba-to-face-big-challenges-ensuring-coronavirus-loans-arent-misspent-11588094140.

    10   13 CFR 120.

    IsRss:
    • cares act
    • client alerts

    Related professionals

    18 comments

    Leave a comment
    1. roger lagasca | Jul 10, 2020
      Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks, I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link  to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  hi was just seeing if you minded a comment. i like your website and the thme you picked is super. I will be back.
    2. rogerlagasca | Jul 10, 2020
      I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The web site style is perfect, the articles is really great cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  I am unable to read articles online very often, but I’m glad I did today.  This is very well written and your points are well-expressed.  Please, don’t ever stop writing.
    3. muqeet | Jul 09, 2020
      hello!! Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community. siesta bar stool
    4. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
    5. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
      Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include. บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.
    6. Michel jorden | Jul 08, 2020
    7. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
      This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value. Im glad to have found this post as its such an interesting one! I am always on the lookout for quality posts and articles so i suppose im lucky to have found this! I hope you will be adding more in the future...
    8. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
      Great knowledge, do anyone mind merely reference back to it situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your site. You have some really great posts and I feel I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please send me an email if interested. Thank you!
    9. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
    10. Michel jorden | Jul 06, 2020
    11. rogerlagasca | Jul 06, 2020
      I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well..  smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
    12. rogerlagasca | Jul 03, 2020
    13. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
      Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. 
    14. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
    15. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
    16. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
    17. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020
      Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject. smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject.
    18. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020

      Leave a comment

      LABOR & EMPLOYMENT

      PH COVID-19 Client Alert Series: CARES Act Fraud Risks for Borrowers and Lenders

      Apr 28, 2020, 14:26 PM
      Publication Type(s):
      Client Alerts
      Exlcude on home page:
      No

      The U.S. Small Business Administration’s (“SBA”) Paycheck Protection Program (“PPP”) launched on April 3, 2020, and in less than two weeks the allocated $349 billion in PPP funds was exhausted. On April 24, 2020, a supplemental relief package with an additional $310 billion in PPP funds was signed into law.

      Given the significant volume of funding being provided in such a quick timeline, difficulties inevitably will arise in complying with statutory and regulatory requirements during the PPP lending process. This volume of expeditious funding carries an inherent risk of fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement. As has been the case with other emergency federal funding, we expect prosecutors will take an aggressive approach in investigating and pursuing allegations of fraud in connection with the use of PPP funds, for both borrowers and lenders.  Earlier today, April 28, 2020, Treasury Secretary Mnuchin made clear that companies can and will face criminal liability for fraud in connection with the receipt of SBA relief funds.1

      CARES Act Oversight Provisions

      Congress and the Attorney General have already made clear that fraud in connection with the procurement and use of Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (“CARES Act”) loans and grants will be investigated and prosecuted aggressively. In a March 16, 2020 memorandum to the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”), the Attorney General urged federal prosecutors to “prioritize the detection, investigation, and prosecution of all criminal conduct related to the current pandemic.”2

      The CARES Act specifically includes several provisions to fund oversight and enforcement of fraud related to the distribution of SBA relief funds, including utilizing existing Offices of the Inspector General (“OIG”) in several federal agencies and creating a new Office of the Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery (“SIGPR”).3 These include:

      • Authorizing criminal penalties, under existing law, for fraud or other misconduct in seeking or using the SBA’s relief funds (Section 1109(i));
      • Creating the SIGPR Office within the U.S. Department of Treasury to coordinate the auditing and investigation of management and spending of funds under any program established under the CARES Act, including the investigation and prosecution of fraud in the procurement and use of CARES Act loans (Section 4018); and
      • Establishing a Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, composed of several Inspectors General, responsible for preventing and detecting fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement of all funds made available to any non-federal entity under the CARES Act, with the authority to conduct a comprehensive audit of all contracts entered into by the federal government pursuant to the CARES Act (Section 15010).

      We previously saw aggressive investigations and enforcement actions by the DOJ, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), and other regulators against financial institutions and their senior executives related to the use of TARP funds following the 2008 Financial Crisis. Now, SIGPR has been given a broad mandate to “conduct, supervise, and coordinate audits and investigations” in connection with the CARES Act, which will likely mean the issuance of large numbers of subpoenas and the referral of cases to the DOJ for at least the five years provided by the CARES Act.

      Fraud Risks for Borrowers in PPP Applications

      As a general matter, any businesses applying for federal funds should take care to ensure that applications, certifications, and any reporting to the government in connection with the funds, are accurate. This diligence is essential given the potential investigative risks and liabilities related to any “fraud on the government,” including:

      • Criminal penalties (prison time and/or fines) for false statements in connection with the PPP, as authorized by the Inspector General Act of 1978, or under other laws criminalizing false statements or fraudulent schemes;
      • Criminal or significant civil liability under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), which carries large penalties for entities and individuals who defraud the government;
      • Criminal or civil liability from audits or investigations connected to the expanded oversight activities by SIGPR; or
      • Qui tam actions brought by whistleblowers.

      Businesses must take time to consider whether they are the type of business for which PPP funds are intended from a common-sense perspective, particularly with continued media scrutiny of certain large entities that received PPP loans. Large businesses or small entities owned by large businesses are not necessarily precluded from applying for PPP loans, but they must be able to truthfully establish eligibility within the guidance. Secretary Mnuchin made clear on April 28, 2020 that all companies that received more than $2 million in small business loans would be audited by the SBA and subject to potential criminal liability if it is later determined that they were ineligible for the SBA relief funds.4  In fact, some large companies that received tens of millions of dollars of SBA loans have already announced plans to return the PPP funds due to public criticism of their participation, although they have not made any acknowledgments regarding their eligibility to receive the funds in the first place.5

      Last week, on April 21, 2020, Secretary Mnuchin announced that the SBA may “give people the benefit of the doubt” if there were any misunderstandings about PPP certifications and a borrower immediately pays back the loan.6 The SBA updated guidance on April 26, 2020 confirms that ineligible borrowers may repay any PPP loan received in full by May 7, 2020 to “be deemed by SBA to have made the required certification [of eligibility] in good faith.”7 As part of the updated guidance, the Treasury and SBA have clarified the certification requirements for borrowers to the extent there was confusion, noting that only entities without access to other forms of capital, such as selling shares or debt, are eligible for the SBA relief funds.8  Businesses that have already received PPP loans should strongly consider whether their certifications regarding loan eligibility will withstand investigative scrutiny and assess whether to take advantage of the opportunity to return the funds by May 7th to avoid potential future criminal or regulatory exposure.

      Fraud Risks for Lenders

      While it is unlikely that financial institutions will be the principal focus of SIGPR or related DOJ investigations, they will inevitably become involved when such investigations begin. The SBA has declared that lenders’ underwriting obligations under the PPP are limited; the SBA has explicitly stated that lenders may rely on borrowers’ representations and certifications in the loan process. In fact, to ensure the new PPP loans reached recipients quickly, banks were largely absolved of the time-consuming responsibility of checking for fraud or egregious errors in loan applications, so long as borrowers provided necessary documentation.9 However, it remains unclear whether such lender protections extend to all of the many potential ways in which lenders may be held accountable in hindsight for borrower misrepresentations made in those applications.

      It is unfortunate but expected that lenders will be involved in FCA and criminal CARES Act fraud inquiries. As financial institutions know well, these inquiries frequently include investigations related to the conduct of lenders, including their internal processes and controls, documentation, diligence, and relationship banker behavior.

      While the SBA’s Interim Final Rule requires only limited due diligence on the part of lenders, it nonetheless requires that lenders “follow their existing [Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”)] protocols when making PPP loans.”10 Prosecutors may therefore also inquire about whether banks followed their own BSA protocols, as well as regulatory or statutory requirements, which could lead to criminal or civil exposure for financial institutions.

      In addition, the SIGPR mandate includes a requirement that it investigate fraud in the “sale of loans” in the secondary markets. This is likely to include inquiries into representations made as part of securitizations or the sale of loan participations. Any alleged false statements made in connection with this type of market activity can be the source of a separate investigation of a financial institution related to the CARES Act.

      Best Practices for Lenders to Mitigate Risks

      Financial institutions have admittedly been thrust in the middle of a rushed loan program with limited guidance and little time to prepare. Nevertheless, banks and bankers must remain vigilant to do what they can in the shortened and urgent application process to identify questionable representations. To avoid potential criminal and regulatory exposure, transparency and accuracy are especially important in the execution of applications for SBA loans under the CARES Act. To the extent possible, financial institutions should:

      1. Create and implement clear, documented processes for assessing the truthfulness of representations in CARES Act loan applications, including a review by compliance personnel, or at a minimum, a bank employee other than the relationship banker;
      2. Document any discussion with a borrower regarding a close question about eligibility or necessity for PPP funds under the law, and require a second review of any application where such a close question is involved;
      3. Confirm that borrowers do not have an alternate source of available funding, such as from a significant shareholder;
      4. Require relationship bankers to regularly seek and maintain documentation regarding any changes in a borrower’s investments or relationships with other business entities or affiliates that may affect eligibility or the eligibility certification;
      5. Collect any description of steps taken by a borrower to establish eligibility (e.g., any amendments to governance documents to irrevocably change control rights between affiliates);
      6. Collect additional documentation from borrowers, beyond the minimum requirements, demonstrating, for example, a decline in available funding through orders, ongoing business operations, or changes in the circumstances of a business’s customers;
      7. Compare borrowers’ assertions about payroll, rent, and other expenses with the Know Your Customer (“KYC”) information in the bank’s files;
      8. Compare any information in a borrower’s files about their affiliates with the list of affiliates that borrowers provide in their CARES Act loan applications, particularly for the counting of affiliate employees for eligibility purposes;
      9. Conduct diligence on the certification that borrowers will be required to submit attesting to the use of loan proceeds in order to obtain loan forgiveness as issues may arise if activity in borrowers’ bank accounts is inconsistent with loan application representations;
      10. Prepare trainings for relevant personnel on the CARES Act funding requirements and any subsequent guidance issued; and
      11. Review internal BSA policies and prepare regular BSA trainings and compliance alerts for bankers during this time.

      While there is a need for financial institutions to act quickly to process CARES Act loan applications, basic compliance procedures and borrower diligence cannot be ignored. Incomplete or inadequate diligence or controls create investigative risks for both lenders and borrowers.



      1 “As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

      2   Memorandum from the Attorney General to all United States Attorneys, COVID-19 – Department of Justice Priorities (Mar. 16, 2020), available at https://www.justice.gov/ag/page/file/1258676/download.

      3  Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, H.R. 748, §§ 4018, 4020, 15010 (2020).

      4 As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

      5 Id.

      7  Paycheck Protection Loans, Frequently Asked Questions (Apr. 26, 2020) available at https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/136/Paycheck-Protection-Program-Frequently-Asked-Questions.pdf.

      8 Id.

      9 Bob Davis, “SBA to Face Big Challenges Ensuring Coronavirus Loans Aren’t Misspent,” Wall St. J. (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/sba-to-face-big-challenges-ensuring-coronavirus-loans-arent-misspent-11588094140.

      10   13 CFR 120.

      IsRss:
      • cares act
      • client alerts

      Related professionals

      18 comments

      Leave a comment
      1. roger lagasca | Jul 10, 2020
        Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks, I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link  to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  hi was just seeing if you minded a comment. i like your website and the thme you picked is super. I will be back.
      2. rogerlagasca | Jul 10, 2020
        I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The web site style is perfect, the articles is really great cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  I am unable to read articles online very often, but I’m glad I did today.  This is very well written and your points are well-expressed.  Please, don’t ever stop writing.
      3. muqeet | Jul 09, 2020
        hello!! Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community. siesta bar stool
      4. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
      5. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
        Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include. บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.
      6. Michel jorden | Jul 08, 2020
      7. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
        This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value. Im glad to have found this post as its such an interesting one! I am always on the lookout for quality posts and articles so i suppose im lucky to have found this! I hope you will be adding more in the future...
      8. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
        Great knowledge, do anyone mind merely reference back to it situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your site. You have some really great posts and I feel I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please send me an email if interested. Thank you!
      9. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
      10. Michel jorden | Jul 06, 2020
      11. rogerlagasca | Jul 06, 2020
        I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well..  smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
      12. rogerlagasca | Jul 03, 2020
      13. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
        Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. 
      14. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
      15. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
      16. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
      17. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020
        Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject. smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject.
      18. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020

        Leave a comment

        FINANCIAL REGULATION & THE CARES ACT

        PH COVID-19 Client Alert Series: CARES Act Fraud Risks for Borrowers and Lenders

        Apr 28, 2020, 14:26 PM
        Publication Type(s):
        Client Alerts
        Exlcude on home page:
        No

        The U.S. Small Business Administration’s (“SBA”) Paycheck Protection Program (“PPP”) launched on April 3, 2020, and in less than two weeks the allocated $349 billion in PPP funds was exhausted. On April 24, 2020, a supplemental relief package with an additional $310 billion in PPP funds was signed into law.

        Given the significant volume of funding being provided in such a quick timeline, difficulties inevitably will arise in complying with statutory and regulatory requirements during the PPP lending process. This volume of expeditious funding carries an inherent risk of fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement. As has been the case with other emergency federal funding, we expect prosecutors will take an aggressive approach in investigating and pursuing allegations of fraud in connection with the use of PPP funds, for both borrowers and lenders.  Earlier today, April 28, 2020, Treasury Secretary Mnuchin made clear that companies can and will face criminal liability for fraud in connection with the receipt of SBA relief funds.1

        CARES Act Oversight Provisions

        Congress and the Attorney General have already made clear that fraud in connection with the procurement and use of Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (“CARES Act”) loans and grants will be investigated and prosecuted aggressively. In a March 16, 2020 memorandum to the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”), the Attorney General urged federal prosecutors to “prioritize the detection, investigation, and prosecution of all criminal conduct related to the current pandemic.”2

        The CARES Act specifically includes several provisions to fund oversight and enforcement of fraud related to the distribution of SBA relief funds, including utilizing existing Offices of the Inspector General (“OIG”) in several federal agencies and creating a new Office of the Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery (“SIGPR”).3 These include:

        • Authorizing criminal penalties, under existing law, for fraud or other misconduct in seeking or using the SBA’s relief funds (Section 1109(i));
        • Creating the SIGPR Office within the U.S. Department of Treasury to coordinate the auditing and investigation of management and spending of funds under any program established under the CARES Act, including the investigation and prosecution of fraud in the procurement and use of CARES Act loans (Section 4018); and
        • Establishing a Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, composed of several Inspectors General, responsible for preventing and detecting fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement of all funds made available to any non-federal entity under the CARES Act, with the authority to conduct a comprehensive audit of all contracts entered into by the federal government pursuant to the CARES Act (Section 15010).

        We previously saw aggressive investigations and enforcement actions by the DOJ, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), and other regulators against financial institutions and their senior executives related to the use of TARP funds following the 2008 Financial Crisis. Now, SIGPR has been given a broad mandate to “conduct, supervise, and coordinate audits and investigations” in connection with the CARES Act, which will likely mean the issuance of large numbers of subpoenas and the referral of cases to the DOJ for at least the five years provided by the CARES Act.

        Fraud Risks for Borrowers in PPP Applications

        As a general matter, any businesses applying for federal funds should take care to ensure that applications, certifications, and any reporting to the government in connection with the funds, are accurate. This diligence is essential given the potential investigative risks and liabilities related to any “fraud on the government,” including:

        • Criminal penalties (prison time and/or fines) for false statements in connection with the PPP, as authorized by the Inspector General Act of 1978, or under other laws criminalizing false statements or fraudulent schemes;
        • Criminal or significant civil liability under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), which carries large penalties for entities and individuals who defraud the government;
        • Criminal or civil liability from audits or investigations connected to the expanded oversight activities by SIGPR; or
        • Qui tam actions brought by whistleblowers.

        Businesses must take time to consider whether they are the type of business for which PPP funds are intended from a common-sense perspective, particularly with continued media scrutiny of certain large entities that received PPP loans. Large businesses or small entities owned by large businesses are not necessarily precluded from applying for PPP loans, but they must be able to truthfully establish eligibility within the guidance. Secretary Mnuchin made clear on April 28, 2020 that all companies that received more than $2 million in small business loans would be audited by the SBA and subject to potential criminal liability if it is later determined that they were ineligible for the SBA relief funds.4  In fact, some large companies that received tens of millions of dollars of SBA loans have already announced plans to return the PPP funds due to public criticism of their participation, although they have not made any acknowledgments regarding their eligibility to receive the funds in the first place.5

        Last week, on April 21, 2020, Secretary Mnuchin announced that the SBA may “give people the benefit of the doubt” if there were any misunderstandings about PPP certifications and a borrower immediately pays back the loan.6 The SBA updated guidance on April 26, 2020 confirms that ineligible borrowers may repay any PPP loan received in full by May 7, 2020 to “be deemed by SBA to have made the required certification [of eligibility] in good faith.”7 As part of the updated guidance, the Treasury and SBA have clarified the certification requirements for borrowers to the extent there was confusion, noting that only entities without access to other forms of capital, such as selling shares or debt, are eligible for the SBA relief funds.8  Businesses that have already received PPP loans should strongly consider whether their certifications regarding loan eligibility will withstand investigative scrutiny and assess whether to take advantage of the opportunity to return the funds by May 7th to avoid potential future criminal or regulatory exposure.

        Fraud Risks for Lenders

        While it is unlikely that financial institutions will be the principal focus of SIGPR or related DOJ investigations, they will inevitably become involved when such investigations begin. The SBA has declared that lenders’ underwriting obligations under the PPP are limited; the SBA has explicitly stated that lenders may rely on borrowers’ representations and certifications in the loan process. In fact, to ensure the new PPP loans reached recipients quickly, banks were largely absolved of the time-consuming responsibility of checking for fraud or egregious errors in loan applications, so long as borrowers provided necessary documentation.9 However, it remains unclear whether such lender protections extend to all of the many potential ways in which lenders may be held accountable in hindsight for borrower misrepresentations made in those applications.

        It is unfortunate but expected that lenders will be involved in FCA and criminal CARES Act fraud inquiries. As financial institutions know well, these inquiries frequently include investigations related to the conduct of lenders, including their internal processes and controls, documentation, diligence, and relationship banker behavior.

        While the SBA’s Interim Final Rule requires only limited due diligence on the part of lenders, it nonetheless requires that lenders “follow their existing [Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”)] protocols when making PPP loans.”10 Prosecutors may therefore also inquire about whether banks followed their own BSA protocols, as well as regulatory or statutory requirements, which could lead to criminal or civil exposure for financial institutions.

        In addition, the SIGPR mandate includes a requirement that it investigate fraud in the “sale of loans” in the secondary markets. This is likely to include inquiries into representations made as part of securitizations or the sale of loan participations. Any alleged false statements made in connection with this type of market activity can be the source of a separate investigation of a financial institution related to the CARES Act.

        Best Practices for Lenders to Mitigate Risks

        Financial institutions have admittedly been thrust in the middle of a rushed loan program with limited guidance and little time to prepare. Nevertheless, banks and bankers must remain vigilant to do what they can in the shortened and urgent application process to identify questionable representations. To avoid potential criminal and regulatory exposure, transparency and accuracy are especially important in the execution of applications for SBA loans under the CARES Act. To the extent possible, financial institutions should:

        1. Create and implement clear, documented processes for assessing the truthfulness of representations in CARES Act loan applications, including a review by compliance personnel, or at a minimum, a bank employee other than the relationship banker;
        2. Document any discussion with a borrower regarding a close question about eligibility or necessity for PPP funds under the law, and require a second review of any application where such a close question is involved;
        3. Confirm that borrowers do not have an alternate source of available funding, such as from a significant shareholder;
        4. Require relationship bankers to regularly seek and maintain documentation regarding any changes in a borrower’s investments or relationships with other business entities or affiliates that may affect eligibility or the eligibility certification;
        5. Collect any description of steps taken by a borrower to establish eligibility (e.g., any amendments to governance documents to irrevocably change control rights between affiliates);
        6. Collect additional documentation from borrowers, beyond the minimum requirements, demonstrating, for example, a decline in available funding through orders, ongoing business operations, or changes in the circumstances of a business’s customers;
        7. Compare borrowers’ assertions about payroll, rent, and other expenses with the Know Your Customer (“KYC”) information in the bank’s files;
        8. Compare any information in a borrower’s files about their affiliates with the list of affiliates that borrowers provide in their CARES Act loan applications, particularly for the counting of affiliate employees for eligibility purposes;
        9. Conduct diligence on the certification that borrowers will be required to submit attesting to the use of loan proceeds in order to obtain loan forgiveness as issues may arise if activity in borrowers’ bank accounts is inconsistent with loan application representations;
        10. Prepare trainings for relevant personnel on the CARES Act funding requirements and any subsequent guidance issued; and
        11. Review internal BSA policies and prepare regular BSA trainings and compliance alerts for bankers during this time.

        While there is a need for financial institutions to act quickly to process CARES Act loan applications, basic compliance procedures and borrower diligence cannot be ignored. Incomplete or inadequate diligence or controls create investigative risks for both lenders and borrowers.



        1 “As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

        2   Memorandum from the Attorney General to all United States Attorneys, COVID-19 – Department of Justice Priorities (Mar. 16, 2020), available at https://www.justice.gov/ag/page/file/1258676/download.

        3  Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, H.R. 748, §§ 4018, 4020, 15010 (2020).

        4 As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

        5 Id.

        7  Paycheck Protection Loans, Frequently Asked Questions (Apr. 26, 2020) available at https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/136/Paycheck-Protection-Program-Frequently-Asked-Questions.pdf.

        8 Id.

        9 Bob Davis, “SBA to Face Big Challenges Ensuring Coronavirus Loans Aren’t Misspent,” Wall St. J. (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/sba-to-face-big-challenges-ensuring-coronavirus-loans-arent-misspent-11588094140.

        10   13 CFR 120.

        IsRss:
        • cares act
        • client alerts

        Related professionals

        18 comments

        Leave a comment
        1. roger lagasca | Jul 10, 2020
          Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks, I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link  to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  hi was just seeing if you minded a comment. i like your website and the thme you picked is super. I will be back.
        2. rogerlagasca | Jul 10, 2020
          I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The web site style is perfect, the articles is really great cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  I am unable to read articles online very often, but I’m glad I did today.  This is very well written and your points are well-expressed.  Please, don’t ever stop writing.
        3. muqeet | Jul 09, 2020
          hello!! Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community. siesta bar stool
        4. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
        5. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
          Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include. บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.
        6. Michel jorden | Jul 08, 2020
        7. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
          This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value. Im glad to have found this post as its such an interesting one! I am always on the lookout for quality posts and articles so i suppose im lucky to have found this! I hope you will be adding more in the future...
        8. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
          Great knowledge, do anyone mind merely reference back to it situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your site. You have some really great posts and I feel I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please send me an email if interested. Thank you!
        9. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
        10. Michel jorden | Jul 06, 2020
        11. rogerlagasca | Jul 06, 2020
          I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well..  smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
        12. rogerlagasca | Jul 03, 2020
        13. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
          Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. 
        14. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
        15. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
        16. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
        17. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020
          Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject. smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject.
        18. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020

          Leave a comment

          ASSET MANAGEMENT

          PH COVID-19 Client Alert Series: CARES Act Fraud Risks for Borrowers and Lenders

          Apr 28, 2020, 14:26 PM
          Publication Type(s):
          Client Alerts
          Exlcude on home page:
          No

          The U.S. Small Business Administration’s (“SBA”) Paycheck Protection Program (“PPP”) launched on April 3, 2020, and in less than two weeks the allocated $349 billion in PPP funds was exhausted. On April 24, 2020, a supplemental relief package with an additional $310 billion in PPP funds was signed into law.

          Given the significant volume of funding being provided in such a quick timeline, difficulties inevitably will arise in complying with statutory and regulatory requirements during the PPP lending process. This volume of expeditious funding carries an inherent risk of fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement. As has been the case with other emergency federal funding, we expect prosecutors will take an aggressive approach in investigating and pursuing allegations of fraud in connection with the use of PPP funds, for both borrowers and lenders.  Earlier today, April 28, 2020, Treasury Secretary Mnuchin made clear that companies can and will face criminal liability for fraud in connection with the receipt of SBA relief funds.1

          CARES Act Oversight Provisions

          Congress and the Attorney General have already made clear that fraud in connection with the procurement and use of Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (“CARES Act”) loans and grants will be investigated and prosecuted aggressively. In a March 16, 2020 memorandum to the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”), the Attorney General urged federal prosecutors to “prioritize the detection, investigation, and prosecution of all criminal conduct related to the current pandemic.”2

          The CARES Act specifically includes several provisions to fund oversight and enforcement of fraud related to the distribution of SBA relief funds, including utilizing existing Offices of the Inspector General (“OIG”) in several federal agencies and creating a new Office of the Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery (“SIGPR”).3 These include:

          • Authorizing criminal penalties, under existing law, for fraud or other misconduct in seeking or using the SBA’s relief funds (Section 1109(i));
          • Creating the SIGPR Office within the U.S. Department of Treasury to coordinate the auditing and investigation of management and spending of funds under any program established under the CARES Act, including the investigation and prosecution of fraud in the procurement and use of CARES Act loans (Section 4018); and
          • Establishing a Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, composed of several Inspectors General, responsible for preventing and detecting fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement of all funds made available to any non-federal entity under the CARES Act, with the authority to conduct a comprehensive audit of all contracts entered into by the federal government pursuant to the CARES Act (Section 15010).

          We previously saw aggressive investigations and enforcement actions by the DOJ, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), and other regulators against financial institutions and their senior executives related to the use of TARP funds following the 2008 Financial Crisis. Now, SIGPR has been given a broad mandate to “conduct, supervise, and coordinate audits and investigations” in connection with the CARES Act, which will likely mean the issuance of large numbers of subpoenas and the referral of cases to the DOJ for at least the five years provided by the CARES Act.

          Fraud Risks for Borrowers in PPP Applications

          As a general matter, any businesses applying for federal funds should take care to ensure that applications, certifications, and any reporting to the government in connection with the funds, are accurate. This diligence is essential given the potential investigative risks and liabilities related to any “fraud on the government,” including:

          • Criminal penalties (prison time and/or fines) for false statements in connection with the PPP, as authorized by the Inspector General Act of 1978, or under other laws criminalizing false statements or fraudulent schemes;
          • Criminal or significant civil liability under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), which carries large penalties for entities and individuals who defraud the government;
          • Criminal or civil liability from audits or investigations connected to the expanded oversight activities by SIGPR; or
          • Qui tam actions brought by whistleblowers.

          Businesses must take time to consider whether they are the type of business for which PPP funds are intended from a common-sense perspective, particularly with continued media scrutiny of certain large entities that received PPP loans. Large businesses or small entities owned by large businesses are not necessarily precluded from applying for PPP loans, but they must be able to truthfully establish eligibility within the guidance. Secretary Mnuchin made clear on April 28, 2020 that all companies that received more than $2 million in small business loans would be audited by the SBA and subject to potential criminal liability if it is later determined that they were ineligible for the SBA relief funds.4  In fact, some large companies that received tens of millions of dollars of SBA loans have already announced plans to return the PPP funds due to public criticism of their participation, although they have not made any acknowledgments regarding their eligibility to receive the funds in the first place.5

          Last week, on April 21, 2020, Secretary Mnuchin announced that the SBA may “give people the benefit of the doubt” if there were any misunderstandings about PPP certifications and a borrower immediately pays back the loan.6 The SBA updated guidance on April 26, 2020 confirms that ineligible borrowers may repay any PPP loan received in full by May 7, 2020 to “be deemed by SBA to have made the required certification [of eligibility] in good faith.”7 As part of the updated guidance, the Treasury and SBA have clarified the certification requirements for borrowers to the extent there was confusion, noting that only entities without access to other forms of capital, such as selling shares or debt, are eligible for the SBA relief funds.8  Businesses that have already received PPP loans should strongly consider whether their certifications regarding loan eligibility will withstand investigative scrutiny and assess whether to take advantage of the opportunity to return the funds by May 7th to avoid potential future criminal or regulatory exposure.

          Fraud Risks for Lenders

          While it is unlikely that financial institutions will be the principal focus of SIGPR or related DOJ investigations, they will inevitably become involved when such investigations begin. The SBA has declared that lenders’ underwriting obligations under the PPP are limited; the SBA has explicitly stated that lenders may rely on borrowers’ representations and certifications in the loan process. In fact, to ensure the new PPP loans reached recipients quickly, banks were largely absolved of the time-consuming responsibility of checking for fraud or egregious errors in loan applications, so long as borrowers provided necessary documentation.9 However, it remains unclear whether such lender protections extend to all of the many potential ways in which lenders may be held accountable in hindsight for borrower misrepresentations made in those applications.

          It is unfortunate but expected that lenders will be involved in FCA and criminal CARES Act fraud inquiries. As financial institutions know well, these inquiries frequently include investigations related to the conduct of lenders, including their internal processes and controls, documentation, diligence, and relationship banker behavior.

          While the SBA’s Interim Final Rule requires only limited due diligence on the part of lenders, it nonetheless requires that lenders “follow their existing [Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”)] protocols when making PPP loans.”10 Prosecutors may therefore also inquire about whether banks followed their own BSA protocols, as well as regulatory or statutory requirements, which could lead to criminal or civil exposure for financial institutions.

          In addition, the SIGPR mandate includes a requirement that it investigate fraud in the “sale of loans” in the secondary markets. This is likely to include inquiries into representations made as part of securitizations or the sale of loan participations. Any alleged false statements made in connection with this type of market activity can be the source of a separate investigation of a financial institution related to the CARES Act.

          Best Practices for Lenders to Mitigate Risks

          Financial institutions have admittedly been thrust in the middle of a rushed loan program with limited guidance and little time to prepare. Nevertheless, banks and bankers must remain vigilant to do what they can in the shortened and urgent application process to identify questionable representations. To avoid potential criminal and regulatory exposure, transparency and accuracy are especially important in the execution of applications for SBA loans under the CARES Act. To the extent possible, financial institutions should:

          1. Create and implement clear, documented processes for assessing the truthfulness of representations in CARES Act loan applications, including a review by compliance personnel, or at a minimum, a bank employee other than the relationship banker;
          2. Document any discussion with a borrower regarding a close question about eligibility or necessity for PPP funds under the law, and require a second review of any application where such a close question is involved;
          3. Confirm that borrowers do not have an alternate source of available funding, such as from a significant shareholder;
          4. Require relationship bankers to regularly seek and maintain documentation regarding any changes in a borrower’s investments or relationships with other business entities or affiliates that may affect eligibility or the eligibility certification;
          5. Collect any description of steps taken by a borrower to establish eligibility (e.g., any amendments to governance documents to irrevocably change control rights between affiliates);
          6. Collect additional documentation from borrowers, beyond the minimum requirements, demonstrating, for example, a decline in available funding through orders, ongoing business operations, or changes in the circumstances of a business’s customers;
          7. Compare borrowers’ assertions about payroll, rent, and other expenses with the Know Your Customer (“KYC”) information in the bank’s files;
          8. Compare any information in a borrower’s files about their affiliates with the list of affiliates that borrowers provide in their CARES Act loan applications, particularly for the counting of affiliate employees for eligibility purposes;
          9. Conduct diligence on the certification that borrowers will be required to submit attesting to the use of loan proceeds in order to obtain loan forgiveness as issues may arise if activity in borrowers’ bank accounts is inconsistent with loan application representations;
          10. Prepare trainings for relevant personnel on the CARES Act funding requirements and any subsequent guidance issued; and
          11. Review internal BSA policies and prepare regular BSA trainings and compliance alerts for bankers during this time.

          While there is a need for financial institutions to act quickly to process CARES Act loan applications, basic compliance procedures and borrower diligence cannot be ignored. Incomplete or inadequate diligence or controls create investigative risks for both lenders and borrowers.



          1 “As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

          2   Memorandum from the Attorney General to all United States Attorneys, COVID-19 – Department of Justice Priorities (Mar. 16, 2020), available at https://www.justice.gov/ag/page/file/1258676/download.

          3  Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, H.R. 748, §§ 4018, 4020, 15010 (2020).

          4 As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

          5 Id.

          7  Paycheck Protection Loans, Frequently Asked Questions (Apr. 26, 2020) available at https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/136/Paycheck-Protection-Program-Frequently-Asked-Questions.pdf.

          8 Id.

          9 Bob Davis, “SBA to Face Big Challenges Ensuring Coronavirus Loans Aren’t Misspent,” Wall St. J. (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/sba-to-face-big-challenges-ensuring-coronavirus-loans-arent-misspent-11588094140.

          10   13 CFR 120.

          IsRss:
          • cares act
          • client alerts

          Related professionals

          18 comments

          Leave a comment
          1. roger lagasca | Jul 10, 2020
            Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks, I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link  to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  hi was just seeing if you minded a comment. i like your website and the thme you picked is super. I will be back.
          2. rogerlagasca | Jul 10, 2020
            I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The web site style is perfect, the articles is really great cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  I am unable to read articles online very often, but I’m glad I did today.  This is very well written and your points are well-expressed.  Please, don’t ever stop writing.
          3. muqeet | Jul 09, 2020
            hello!! Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community. siesta bar stool
          4. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
          5. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
            Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include. บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.
          6. Michel jorden | Jul 08, 2020
          7. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
            This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value. Im glad to have found this post as its such an interesting one! I am always on the lookout for quality posts and articles so i suppose im lucky to have found this! I hope you will be adding more in the future...
          8. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
            Great knowledge, do anyone mind merely reference back to it situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your site. You have some really great posts and I feel I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please send me an email if interested. Thank you!
          9. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
          10. Michel jorden | Jul 06, 2020
          11. rogerlagasca | Jul 06, 2020
            I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well..  smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
          12. rogerlagasca | Jul 03, 2020
          13. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
            Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. 
          14. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
          15. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
          16. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
          17. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020
            Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject. smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject.
          18. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020

            Leave a comment

            TAX LAW

            PH COVID-19 Client Alert Series: CARES Act Fraud Risks for Borrowers and Lenders

            Apr 28, 2020, 14:26 PM
            Publication Type(s):
            Client Alerts
            Exlcude on home page:
            No

            The U.S. Small Business Administration’s (“SBA”) Paycheck Protection Program (“PPP”) launched on April 3, 2020, and in less than two weeks the allocated $349 billion in PPP funds was exhausted. On April 24, 2020, a supplemental relief package with an additional $310 billion in PPP funds was signed into law.

            Given the significant volume of funding being provided in such a quick timeline, difficulties inevitably will arise in complying with statutory and regulatory requirements during the PPP lending process. This volume of expeditious funding carries an inherent risk of fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement. As has been the case with other emergency federal funding, we expect prosecutors will take an aggressive approach in investigating and pursuing allegations of fraud in connection with the use of PPP funds, for both borrowers and lenders.  Earlier today, April 28, 2020, Treasury Secretary Mnuchin made clear that companies can and will face criminal liability for fraud in connection with the receipt of SBA relief funds.1

            CARES Act Oversight Provisions

            Congress and the Attorney General have already made clear that fraud in connection with the procurement and use of Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (“CARES Act”) loans and grants will be investigated and prosecuted aggressively. In a March 16, 2020 memorandum to the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”), the Attorney General urged federal prosecutors to “prioritize the detection, investigation, and prosecution of all criminal conduct related to the current pandemic.”2

            The CARES Act specifically includes several provisions to fund oversight and enforcement of fraud related to the distribution of SBA relief funds, including utilizing existing Offices of the Inspector General (“OIG”) in several federal agencies and creating a new Office of the Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery (“SIGPR”).3 These include:

            • Authorizing criminal penalties, under existing law, for fraud or other misconduct in seeking or using the SBA’s relief funds (Section 1109(i));
            • Creating the SIGPR Office within the U.S. Department of Treasury to coordinate the auditing and investigation of management and spending of funds under any program established under the CARES Act, including the investigation and prosecution of fraud in the procurement and use of CARES Act loans (Section 4018); and
            • Establishing a Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, composed of several Inspectors General, responsible for preventing and detecting fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement of all funds made available to any non-federal entity under the CARES Act, with the authority to conduct a comprehensive audit of all contracts entered into by the federal government pursuant to the CARES Act (Section 15010).

            We previously saw aggressive investigations and enforcement actions by the DOJ, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), and other regulators against financial institutions and their senior executives related to the use of TARP funds following the 2008 Financial Crisis. Now, SIGPR has been given a broad mandate to “conduct, supervise, and coordinate audits and investigations” in connection with the CARES Act, which will likely mean the issuance of large numbers of subpoenas and the referral of cases to the DOJ for at least the five years provided by the CARES Act.

            Fraud Risks for Borrowers in PPP Applications

            As a general matter, any businesses applying for federal funds should take care to ensure that applications, certifications, and any reporting to the government in connection with the funds, are accurate. This diligence is essential given the potential investigative risks and liabilities related to any “fraud on the government,” including:

            • Criminal penalties (prison time and/or fines) for false statements in connection with the PPP, as authorized by the Inspector General Act of 1978, or under other laws criminalizing false statements or fraudulent schemes;
            • Criminal or significant civil liability under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), which carries large penalties for entities and individuals who defraud the government;
            • Criminal or civil liability from audits or investigations connected to the expanded oversight activities by SIGPR; or
            • Qui tam actions brought by whistleblowers.

            Businesses must take time to consider whether they are the type of business for which PPP funds are intended from a common-sense perspective, particularly with continued media scrutiny of certain large entities that received PPP loans. Large businesses or small entities owned by large businesses are not necessarily precluded from applying for PPP loans, but they must be able to truthfully establish eligibility within the guidance. Secretary Mnuchin made clear on April 28, 2020 that all companies that received more than $2 million in small business loans would be audited by the SBA and subject to potential criminal liability if it is later determined that they were ineligible for the SBA relief funds.4  In fact, some large companies that received tens of millions of dollars of SBA loans have already announced plans to return the PPP funds due to public criticism of their participation, although they have not made any acknowledgments regarding their eligibility to receive the funds in the first place.5

            Last week, on April 21, 2020, Secretary Mnuchin announced that the SBA may “give people the benefit of the doubt” if there were any misunderstandings about PPP certifications and a borrower immediately pays back the loan.6 The SBA updated guidance on April 26, 2020 confirms that ineligible borrowers may repay any PPP loan received in full by May 7, 2020 to “be deemed by SBA to have made the required certification [of eligibility] in good faith.”7 As part of the updated guidance, the Treasury and SBA have clarified the certification requirements for borrowers to the extent there was confusion, noting that only entities without access to other forms of capital, such as selling shares or debt, are eligible for the SBA relief funds.8  Businesses that have already received PPP loans should strongly consider whether their certifications regarding loan eligibility will withstand investigative scrutiny and assess whether to take advantage of the opportunity to return the funds by May 7th to avoid potential future criminal or regulatory exposure.

            Fraud Risks for Lenders

            While it is unlikely that financial institutions will be the principal focus of SIGPR or related DOJ investigations, they will inevitably become involved when such investigations begin. The SBA has declared that lenders’ underwriting obligations under the PPP are limited; the SBA has explicitly stated that lenders may rely on borrowers’ representations and certifications in the loan process. In fact, to ensure the new PPP loans reached recipients quickly, banks were largely absolved of the time-consuming responsibility of checking for fraud or egregious errors in loan applications, so long as borrowers provided necessary documentation.9 However, it remains unclear whether such lender protections extend to all of the many potential ways in which lenders may be held accountable in hindsight for borrower misrepresentations made in those applications.

            It is unfortunate but expected that lenders will be involved in FCA and criminal CARES Act fraud inquiries. As financial institutions know well, these inquiries frequently include investigations related to the conduct of lenders, including their internal processes and controls, documentation, diligence, and relationship banker behavior.

            While the SBA’s Interim Final Rule requires only limited due diligence on the part of lenders, it nonetheless requires that lenders “follow their existing [Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”)] protocols when making PPP loans.”10 Prosecutors may therefore also inquire about whether banks followed their own BSA protocols, as well as regulatory or statutory requirements, which could lead to criminal or civil exposure for financial institutions.

            In addition, the SIGPR mandate includes a requirement that it investigate fraud in the “sale of loans” in the secondary markets. This is likely to include inquiries into representations made as part of securitizations or the sale of loan participations. Any alleged false statements made in connection with this type of market activity can be the source of a separate investigation of a financial institution related to the CARES Act.

            Best Practices for Lenders to Mitigate Risks

            Financial institutions have admittedly been thrust in the middle of a rushed loan program with limited guidance and little time to prepare. Nevertheless, banks and bankers must remain vigilant to do what they can in the shortened and urgent application process to identify questionable representations. To avoid potential criminal and regulatory exposure, transparency and accuracy are especially important in the execution of applications for SBA loans under the CARES Act. To the extent possible, financial institutions should:

            1. Create and implement clear, documented processes for assessing the truthfulness of representations in CARES Act loan applications, including a review by compliance personnel, or at a minimum, a bank employee other than the relationship banker;
            2. Document any discussion with a borrower regarding a close question about eligibility or necessity for PPP funds under the law, and require a second review of any application where such a close question is involved;
            3. Confirm that borrowers do not have an alternate source of available funding, such as from a significant shareholder;
            4. Require relationship bankers to regularly seek and maintain documentation regarding any changes in a borrower’s investments or relationships with other business entities or affiliates that may affect eligibility or the eligibility certification;
            5. Collect any description of steps taken by a borrower to establish eligibility (e.g., any amendments to governance documents to irrevocably change control rights between affiliates);
            6. Collect additional documentation from borrowers, beyond the minimum requirements, demonstrating, for example, a decline in available funding through orders, ongoing business operations, or changes in the circumstances of a business’s customers;
            7. Compare borrowers’ assertions about payroll, rent, and other expenses with the Know Your Customer (“KYC”) information in the bank’s files;
            8. Compare any information in a borrower’s files about their affiliates with the list of affiliates that borrowers provide in their CARES Act loan applications, particularly for the counting of affiliate employees for eligibility purposes;
            9. Conduct diligence on the certification that borrowers will be required to submit attesting to the use of loan proceeds in order to obtain loan forgiveness as issues may arise if activity in borrowers’ bank accounts is inconsistent with loan application representations;
            10. Prepare trainings for relevant personnel on the CARES Act funding requirements and any subsequent guidance issued; and
            11. Review internal BSA policies and prepare regular BSA trainings and compliance alerts for bankers during this time.

            While there is a need for financial institutions to act quickly to process CARES Act loan applications, basic compliance procedures and borrower diligence cannot be ignored. Incomplete or inadequate diligence or controls create investigative risks for both lenders and borrowers.



            1 “As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

            2   Memorandum from the Attorney General to all United States Attorneys, COVID-19 – Department of Justice Priorities (Mar. 16, 2020), available at https://www.justice.gov/ag/page/file/1258676/download.

            3  Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, H.R. 748, §§ 4018, 4020, 15010 (2020).

            4 As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

            5 Id.

            7  Paycheck Protection Loans, Frequently Asked Questions (Apr. 26, 2020) available at https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/136/Paycheck-Protection-Program-Frequently-Asked-Questions.pdf.

            8 Id.

            9 Bob Davis, “SBA to Face Big Challenges Ensuring Coronavirus Loans Aren’t Misspent,” Wall St. J. (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/sba-to-face-big-challenges-ensuring-coronavirus-loans-arent-misspent-11588094140.

            10   13 CFR 120.

            IsRss:
            • cares act
            • client alerts

            Related professionals

            18 comments

            Leave a comment
            1. roger lagasca | Jul 10, 2020
              Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks, I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link  to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  hi was just seeing if you minded a comment. i like your website and the thme you picked is super. I will be back.
            2. rogerlagasca | Jul 10, 2020
              I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The web site style is perfect, the articles is really great cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  cupom de desconto  I am unable to read articles online very often, but I’m glad I did today.  This is very well written and your points are well-expressed.  Please, don’t ever stop writing.
            3. muqeet | Jul 09, 2020
              hello!! Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community. siesta bar stool
            4. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
            5. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
              Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include. บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  บ้านบอล  Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.
            6. Michel jorden | Jul 08, 2020
            7. rogerlagasca | Jul 08, 2020
              This type of message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value. Im glad to have found this post as its such an interesting one! I am always on the lookout for quality posts and articles so i suppose im lucky to have found this! I hope you will be adding more in the future...
            8. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
              Great knowledge, do anyone mind merely reference back to it situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  situs judi  Please let me know if you’re looking for a article writer for your site. You have some really great posts and I feel I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d absolutely love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please send me an email if interested. Thank you!
            9. rogerlagasca | Jul 07, 2020
            10. Michel jorden | Jul 06, 2020
            11. rogerlagasca | Jul 06, 2020
              I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well..  smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
            12. rogerlagasca | Jul 03, 2020
            13. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
              Thanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family. buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours buy youtube watch hours Its a great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work. 
            14. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
            15. rogerlagasca | Jul 01, 2020
            16. Michel jorden | Jul 01, 2020
            17. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020
              Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject. smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel smm panel Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research. Thanks for posting, maybe we can see more on this. Are you aware of any other websites on this subject.
            18. rogerlagasca | Jun 30, 2020

              Leave a comment

              REAL ESTATE & HOSPITALITY

              PH COVID-19 Client Alert Series: CARES Act Fraud Risks for Borrowers and Lenders

              Apr 28, 2020, 14:26 PM
              Publication Type(s):
              Client Alerts
              Exlcude on home page:
              No

              The U.S. Small Business Administration’s (“SBA”) Paycheck Protection Program (“PPP”) launched on April 3, 2020, and in less than two weeks the allocated $349 billion in PPP funds was exhausted. On April 24, 2020, a supplemental relief package with an additional $310 billion in PPP funds was signed into law.

              Given the significant volume of funding being provided in such a quick timeline, difficulties inevitably will arise in complying with statutory and regulatory requirements during the PPP lending process. This volume of expeditious funding carries an inherent risk of fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement. As has been the case with other emergency federal funding, we expect prosecutors will take an aggressive approach in investigating and pursuing allegations of fraud in connection with the use of PPP funds, for both borrowers and lenders.  Earlier today, April 28, 2020, Treasury Secretary Mnuchin made clear that companies can and will face criminal liability for fraud in connection with the receipt of SBA relief funds.1

              CARES Act Oversight Provisions

              Congress and the Attorney General have already made clear that fraud in connection with the procurement and use of Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (“CARES Act”) loans and grants will be investigated and prosecuted aggressively. In a March 16, 2020 memorandum to the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”), the Attorney General urged federal prosecutors to “prioritize the detection, investigation, and prosecution of all criminal conduct related to the current pandemic.”2

              The CARES Act specifically includes several provisions to fund oversight and enforcement of fraud related to the distribution of SBA relief funds, including utilizing existing Offices of the Inspector General (“OIG”) in several federal agencies and creating a new Office of the Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery (“SIGPR”).3 These include:

              • Authorizing criminal penalties, under existing law, for fraud or other misconduct in seeking or using the SBA’s relief funds (Section 1109(i));
              • Creating the SIGPR Office within the U.S. Department of Treasury to coordinate the auditing and investigation of management and spending of funds under any program established under the CARES Act, including the investigation and prosecution of fraud in the procurement and use of CARES Act loans (Section 4018); and
              • Establishing a Pandemic Response Accountability Committee, composed of several Inspectors General, responsible for preventing and detecting fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement of all funds made available to any non-federal entity under the CARES Act, with the authority to conduct a comprehensive audit of all contracts entered into by the federal government pursuant to the CARES Act (Section 15010).

              We previously saw aggressive investigations and enforcement actions by the DOJ, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), and other regulators against financial institutions and their senior executives related to the use of TARP funds following the 2008 Financial Crisis. Now, SIGPR has been given a broad mandate to “conduct, supervise, and coordinate audits and investigations” in connection with the CARES Act, which will likely mean the issuance of large numbers of subpoenas and the referral of cases to the DOJ for at least the five years provided by the CARES Act.

              Fraud Risks for Borrowers in PPP Applications

              As a general matter, any businesses applying for federal funds should take care to ensure that applications, certifications, and any reporting to the government in connection with the funds, are accurate. This diligence is essential given the potential investigative risks and liabilities related to any “fraud on the government,” including:

              • Criminal penalties (prison time and/or fines) for false statements in connection with the PPP, as authorized by the Inspector General Act of 1978, or under other laws criminalizing false statements or fraudulent schemes;
              • Criminal or significant civil liability under the False Claims Act (“FCA”), which carries large penalties for entities and individuals who defraud the government;
              • Criminal or civil liability from audits or investigations connected to the expanded oversight activities by SIGPR; or
              • Qui tam actions brought by whistleblowers.

              Businesses must take time to consider whether they are the type of business for which PPP funds are intended from a common-sense perspective, particularly with continued media scrutiny of certain large entities that received PPP loans. Large businesses or small entities owned by large businesses are not necessarily precluded from applying for PPP loans, but they must be able to truthfully establish eligibility within the guidance. Secretary Mnuchin made clear on April 28, 2020 that all companies that received more than $2 million in small business loans would be audited by the SBA and subject to potential criminal liability if it is later determined that they were ineligible for the SBA relief funds.4  In fact, some large companies that received tens of millions of dollars of SBA loans have already announced plans to return the PPP funds due to public criticism of their participation, although they have not made any acknowledgments regarding their eligibility to receive the funds in the first place.5

              Last week, on April 21, 2020, Secretary Mnuchin announced that the SBA may “give people the benefit of the doubt” if there were any misunderstandings about PPP certifications and a borrower immediately pays back the loan.6 The SBA updated guidance on April 26, 2020 confirms that ineligible borrowers may repay any PPP loan received in full by May 7, 2020 to “be deemed by SBA to have made the required certification [of eligibility] in good faith.”7 As part of the updated guidance, the Treasury and SBA have clarified the certification requirements for borrowers to the extent there was confusion, noting that only entities without access to other forms of capital, such as selling shares or debt, are eligible for the SBA relief funds.8  Businesses that have already received PPP loans should strongly consider whether their certifications regarding loan eligibility will withstand investigative scrutiny and assess whether to take advantage of the opportunity to return the funds by May 7th to avoid potential future criminal or regulatory exposure.

              Fraud Risks for Lenders

              While it is unlikely that financial institutions will be the principal focus of SIGPR or related DOJ investigations, they will inevitably become involved when such investigations begin. The SBA has declared that lenders’ underwriting obligations under the PPP are limited; the SBA has explicitly stated that lenders may rely on borrowers’ representations and certifications in the loan process. In fact, to ensure the new PPP loans reached recipients quickly, banks were largely absolved of the time-consuming responsibility of checking for fraud or egregious errors in loan applications, so long as borrowers provided necessary documentation.9 However, it remains unclear whether such lender protections extend to all of the many potential ways in which lenders may be held accountable in hindsight for borrower misrepresentations made in those applications.

              It is unfortunate but expected that lenders will be involved in FCA and criminal CARES Act fraud inquiries. As financial institutions know well, these inquiries frequently include investigations related to the conduct of lenders, including their internal processes and controls, documentation, diligence, and relationship banker behavior.

              While the SBA’s Interim Final Rule requires only limited due diligence on the part of lenders, it nonetheless requires that lenders “follow their existing [Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”)] protocols when making PPP loans.”10 Prosecutors may therefore also inquire about whether banks followed their own BSA protocols, as well as regulatory or statutory requirements, which could lead to criminal or civil exposure for financial institutions.

              In addition, the SIGPR mandate includes a requirement that it investigate fraud in the “sale of loans” in the secondary markets. This is likely to include inquiries into representations made as part of securitizations or the sale of loan participations. Any alleged false statements made in connection with this type of market activity can be the source of a separate investigation of a financial institution related to the CARES Act.

              Best Practices for Lenders to Mitigate Risks

              Financial institutions have admittedly been thrust in the middle of a rushed loan program with limited guidance and little time to prepare. Nevertheless, banks and bankers must remain vigilant to do what they can in the shortened and urgent application process to identify questionable representations. To avoid potential criminal and regulatory exposure, transparency and accuracy are especially important in the execution of applications for SBA loans under the CARES Act. To the extent possible, financial institutions should:

              1. Create and implement clear, documented processes for assessing the truthfulness of representations in CARES Act loan applications, including a review by compliance personnel, or at a minimum, a bank employee other than the relationship banker;
              2. Document any discussion with a borrower regarding a close question about eligibility or necessity for PPP funds under the law, and require a second review of any application where such a close question is involved;
              3. Confirm that borrowers do not have an alternate source of available funding, such as from a significant shareholder;
              4. Require relationship bankers to regularly seek and maintain documentation regarding any changes in a borrower’s investments or relationships with other business entities or affiliates that may affect eligibility or the eligibility certification;
              5. Collect any description of steps taken by a borrower to establish eligibility (e.g., any amendments to governance documents to irrevocably change control rights between affiliates);
              6. Collect additional documentation from borrowers, beyond the minimum requirements, demonstrating, for example, a decline in available funding through orders, ongoing business operations, or changes in the circumstances of a business’s customers;
              7. Compare borrowers’ assertions about payroll, rent, and other expenses with the Know Your Customer (“KYC”) information in the bank’s files;
              8. Compare any information in a borrower’s files about their affiliates with the list of affiliates that borrowers provide in their CARES Act loan applications, particularly for the counting of affiliate employees for eligibility purposes;
              9. Conduct diligence on the certification that borrowers will be required to submit attesting to the use of loan proceeds in order to obtain loan forgiveness as issues may arise if activity in borrowers’ bank accounts is inconsistent with loan application representations;
              10. Prepare trainings for relevant personnel on the CARES Act funding requirements and any subsequent guidance issued; and
              11. Review internal BSA policies and prepare regular BSA trainings and compliance alerts for bankers during this time.

              While there is a need for financial institutions to act quickly to process CARES Act loan applications, basic compliance procedures and borrower diligence cannot be ignored. Incomplete or inadequate diligence or controls create investigative risks for both lenders and borrowers.



              1 “As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

              2   Memorandum from the Attorney General to all United States Attorneys, COVID-19 – Department of Justice Priorities (Mar. 16, 2020), available at https://www.justice.gov/ag/page/file/1258676/download.

              3  Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, H.R. 748, §§ 4018, 4020, 15010 (2020).

              4 As the Lakers and Others Return Small Business Aid, Mnuchin Says Big Companies Could Face ‘Criminal Liability,” N.Y. Times (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/28/us/coronavirus-updates.html.

              5 Id.

              7  Paycheck Protection Loans, Frequently Asked Questions (Apr. 26, 2020) available at https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/136/Paycheck-Protection-Program-Frequently-Asked-Questions.pdf.

              8 Id.

              9 Bob Davis, “SBA to Face Big Challenges Ensuring Coronavirus Loans Aren’t Misspent,” Wall St. J. (Apr. 28, 2020), available at https://www.wsj.com/articles/sba-to-face-big-challenges-ensuring-coronavirus-loans-arent-misspent-11588094140.

              10   13 CFR 120.

              IsRss:
              • cares act
              • client alerts

              Related professionals

              18 comments

              Leave a comment
              1. roger lagasca | Jul 10, 2020
                Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks, I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link  to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast  Podcast