Thought Leadership
NOVEMBER 17, 2026
Law360 Expert Analysis: How 9th Circ. Applied 1st Amendment To Climate Disclosures
Read Time: 2 min
In a Law360 Expert Analysis, Environmental Litigation co-chair Brian Israel and associate Chelsea Nielsen examine the Ninth Circuit’s Nov. 9, 2026 decision in Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, which addressed the constitutionality of California’s climate disclosure laws. Reviewing the denial of a preliminary injunction, the Ninth Circuit allowed Scope 1 and 2 emissions reporting requirements to remain in effect but concluded that Scope 3 emissions and climate-related financial risk disclosures likely violate the First Amendment.
The authors analyze the court’s reasoning, potential next steps in the litigation, and broader legal and practical implications.
Read the full article here.