Skip to Main Content
Thought Leadership

President Nominates SEC and CFTC Commissioners, CFTC Rejects Geographic Limits on DCM Access and SEC Submits Crypto Broker-Dealer Rule

Read Time: 9 min

CONTRIBUTORS

Chris Daniel

Partner, Fintech & Payments Group

Eric C. Sibbitt

Partner, Fintech & Payments Group

Dana V. Syracuse

Partner, Fintech & Payments Group

Josh Boehm

Partner, Fintech & Payments Group

Meagan E. Griffin

Partner, Fintech & Payments Group

Jaime Madell

Partner, Structured Credit

Kristofer Readling

Of Counsel, Fintech & Payments Group

Lisa E. Rubin

Associate, Fintech & Payments Group

AJ Wei

Associate, Structured Credit

The President sent the Senate four nominations to fill vacant seats at the SEC and CFTC. All four nominees require Senate confirmation. The SEC currently has two of its five seats filled. Chairman Michael Selig is currently the CFTC’s only sitting commissioner. The SEC submitted a proposed crypto broker-dealer rule to the White House for review and filed an amicus brief supporting the CFTC in a lawsuit challenging the CFTC’s approval of perpetual futures contracts on individual equity securities.

The CFTC issued an interpretation stating that designated contract markets (DCMs), including prediction market platforms, generally may not restrict access to their markets based on where an otherwise eligible trader is located within the U.S., setting up a direct conflict with states seeking to block prediction market offerings. A prediction markets platform partly relied on the interpretation in a lawsuit challenging Missouri’s enforcement of its sports wagering laws.

The CFTC’s Division of Clearing and Risk issued a no-action letter stating it will not recommend enforcement action against a derivatives clearing organization (DCO) that uses a trust company to conduct daily settlements with clearing members, provided the DCO treats the trust company as if it were a settlement bank for purposes of Regulations 39.14(c) and (d). FinCEN, the Treasury and the Federal Reserve Board withdrew a 2020 proposal to lower the recordkeeping and travel rule threshold for cross-border funds transfers.

Regulatory Updates

President Nominates SEC and CFTC Commissioners

  • On Nov. 12, the President sent the Senate four nominations to fill vacant seats at the SEC and CFTC. All four nominees require Senate confirmation. The Senate Banking Committee has scheduled a hearing on the SEC nominees for Nov. 19. The SEC currently has two of its five seats filled. Chairman Michael Selig is currently the CFTC’s only sitting commissioner.
  • For the SEC, the President nominated Steven Levine to succeed former Commissioner Hester Peirce, who led the SEC’s Crypto Task Force, for a term expiring June 5, 2030. The President also nominated former CFTC Commissioner Kristin N. Johnson to succeed former Commissioner Caroline Crenshaw for a term expiring June 5, 2029. For the CFTC, the President nominated Nathan Anonick for a term expiring June 19, 2031, and Matthew Rowland for the remainder of a term expiring April 13, 2028.

SEC Submits Broker-Dealer Rule to White House

  • On Nov. 3, the SEC submitted a proposed rule titled “Amendments to Broker-Dealer Financial Responsibility and Recordkeeping and Reporting Rules Regarding Crypto Assets” (3235-AN48) to the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs for review. According to the SEC’s regulatory agenda, the proposal would amend Rules 15c3-1 (Net Capital Rule) and 15c3-3 (Customer Protection Rule) and other broker-dealer financial responsibility rules, as well as recordkeeping Rules 17a-3 and 17a-4, to address how these rules apply to crypto assets. The SEC has designated the rulemaking as economically significant. The text of the proposal is not yet public.

SEC Backs CFTC in Stock Perpetuals Challenge

  • On Nov. 9, the SEC filed an amicus brief in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York supporting the CFTC in a lawsuit challenging the CFTC’s approval of perpetual futures contracts on individual equity securities (“equity perpetuals”). The SEC rejected the plaintiff trade group’s depiction of “a CFTC gone rogue, and an SEC gone missing,” arguing that equity perpetuals, as security futures, remain subject to the SEC's antifraud, anti-manipulation and insider trading authority, as well as its oversight of intermediaries and trading rules.
  • The lawsuit followed the CFTC’s Nov. 3 announcement that equity perpetuals can begin trading for the first time on DCMs that are notice-registered with the SEC as national securities exchanges to trade security futures products. The contracts were deemed approved as security futures products.

CFTC Declares Use of Geographic Access Restrictions Inconsistent With Impartial Access Requirements

  • On Nov. 5, the CFTC issued an interpretation stating that DCMs, including prediction market platforms, generally may not restrict access to their markets based on where an otherwise eligible trader is located within the U.S. The CFTC concluded that state-by-state restrictions on event contracts violate the impartial access requirement of Commission Regulation 38.151(b). DCMs have 30 days to lift these restrictions and ensure that brokers and other intermediaries are not imposing them, or else explain to the CFTC why compliance is not feasible. The interpretation sets up a direct conflict with states that are pursuing litigation, and in some cases obtaining court orders, to block prediction market offerings within their borders. The interpretation took effect Nov. 10.

CFTC Staff Addresses Use of Trust Companies for Daily Settlements

  • On Nov. 5, the CFTC’s Division of Clearing and Risk issued a no-action letter stating that it will not recommend enforcement action against a DCO that uses a trust company to conduct daily settlements with clearing members, provided the DCO treats the trust company as if it were a settlement bank for purposes of Regulations 39.14(c) and (d). The relief responds to a request from a registered DCO that clears for a crypto derivatives exchange and addresses a gap in Regulation 39.14, which defines a “settlement bank” as “a bank” and does not reference trust companies. The requesting DCO stated that the relief will make it easier for DCOs to accept digital assets as margin.

SEC Holds Machine-Understandable Data and Super Intelligence Roundtable

  • On Nov. 9, the SEC held a roundtable focused on machine-understandable data and “super intelligence” (SI). The program featured panel discussions exploring how market participants use SI and machine‑understandable data, the associated risks and costs, and ways the SEC can further support and enhance the use of these technologies. Chairman Paul Atkins delivered closing remarks stating that “better data need not mean more disclosure” and that the greater opportunity often lies in making the information companies already disclose more accessible and useful, without imposing unnecessary burdens on issuers. The SEC did not announce any new rules or requirements following the roundtable.

Federal Agencies Withdraw Proposed Recordkeeping and Travel Rule

  • On Nov. 9, FinCEN, the Treasury and the Federal Reserve Board withdrew a joint notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) published on Oct. 27, 2020, that proposed modifying the threshold in the agencies’ rules implementing the Bank Secrecy Act requiring financial institutions to collect and retain information on certain funds transfers and transmittals of funds.
  • The NPRM would have reduced this threshold from $3,000 to $250 for funds transfers and transmittals of funds that begin or end outside the U.S. FinCEN additionally proposed reducing from $3,000 to $250 the threshold in its rule requiring financial institutions to transmit to other financial institutions in the payment chain information on funds transfers and transmittals of funds that begin or end outside the U.S. The NPRM also would have clarified the meaning of “money” as used in the agencies’ rules to specify that the rules apply to domestic and cross-border transactions involving convertible virtual currency (CVC) and digital assets that have legal tender status to a recipient. The agencies will not take further action on the NPRM.

Additional Updates

Prediction Market Updates

  • On Nov. 9, a prediction markets platform filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri against the Missouri Attorney General and members of the Missouri Gaming Commission, seeking declaratory and injunctive relief barring the state from enforcing its sports wagering laws against the platform. The suit follows a September cease-and-desist letter from the Attorney General demanding that the platform either stop offering sports-related event contracts to Missouri residents or obtain a state gaming license. The platform argues that Missouri’s laws are preempted by the Commodity Exchange Act and violate the Commerce Clause, and cites the CFTC’s impartial access interpretation in arguing that geographically restricting Missouri users would violate federal requirements.
  • On Nov. 4, the Arkansas Attorney General filed a lawsuit against a prediction markets platform in the Circuit Court of Independence County, Arkansas, alleging that the platform operates an unlicensed gambling business, including by offering contracts to users under 21. The complaint asserts claims under the Arkansas Deceptive Trade Practices Act and for unjust enrichment, alleging the platform misrepresented its products as legal and failed to disclose the risk of losses, and seeks to halt the platform's Arkansas operations, restitution for Arkansas consumers, and civil penalties.
  • On Nov. 4, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California granted a preliminary injunction barring a prediction markets platform from offering sports event contracts on the plaintiff Tribes’ lands and ordered the Tribes to provide the platform with maps of their lands by Nov. 13. The order follows a Ninth Circuit decision holding that the Tribes were likely to succeed on their claims that the platform's sports event contracts constitute class III gaming that violates the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act when offered on tribal lands, and that the Commodity Exchange Act’s grant of exclusive jurisdiction to the CFTC does not displace that statute.

RELATED PRACTICES